My Healthy Shape

I review prior authorizations for a health insurance company. My job is to deny the weight-loss shots. I've stamped "DENIED" on over 6,000 of them, most for women over 50. Here's what I wish I could write in the comment box.

I'm going to tell you something about the weight-loss shots that the insurance companies will never say out loud. I know, because I work for one. I'm a prior-authorization reviewer. When your doctor prescribes something expensive, before your insurance will pay for it, the request comes to someone like me. I sit in a cubicle in Hartford, Connecticut, with two monitors and a headset, and I review it against our coverage criteria. For the last three years, a huge part of my job has been the GLP-1 shots. Ozempic. Wegovy. Mounjaro. Zepbound. And for most of the requests that come across my screen for weight loss alone, my job is to deny them. I've stamped "DENIED" on over six thousand of them. I keep a rough count. I don't know why. Maybe so I'll never forget. And most of them, by a wide margin, were for women over 50. If you're one of those women, or you're afraid you'll be one, please read this whole thing. It's long. I'm sorry. I spend all day reading medical records. I've forgotten how to write short. But I'm going to tell you what I see in those records, and what I finally found out. Let me explain how it works. Your doctor sends a request. It comes with your chart notes. Your weight. Your BMI. Your labs. Your history. I read all of it. And then I check it against a list. Does she have type 2 diabetes? If yes, it might be covered. If not, does her plan cover weight loss drugs at all? Most don't. If it does, does she meet the BMI cutoff? Has she documented six months of "lifestyle modification"? Has she tried cheaper options first? If she doesn't check every box, I click "DENIED," pick a reason code from a dropdown menu, and move on to the next one. It takes me about four minutes. Four minutes to tell a woman she can't have the thing her doctor said she needs. Now let me tell you what's in those charts. Because I read every one. And after three years, the charts of women over 50 all start to sound the same. "Patient reports weight gain beginning around age 50, primarily abdominal." "Patient reports adherence to 1,200 kcal/day diet without significant results." "Patient walks daily. Reports persistent hunger and food preoccupation." "Patient has tried commercial weight loss programs x3." "Patient is frustrated and tearful." "Patient is frustrated and tearful." I've read that sentence hundreds of times. Doctors write it in the notes like a vital sign. Weight. Blood pressure. Frustrated and tearful. And then I deny the claim. Let me tell you about a few of them. No names. I'd lose my job, and they deserve their privacy. A 58-year-old schoolteacher from New Haven. Her chart said she'd been on a 1,200-calorie diet "for approximately five years, with minimal results." Abdominal weight gain beginning at 51. Prediabetic, but not diabetic. Her doctor wrote a whole paragraph begging for an exception. DENIED. Code W-4: does not meet diabetes criteria; plan excludes weight management agents. A 63-year-old widow from Waterbury. Her chart said she'd tried "Weight Watchers, Nutrisystem, keto diet, and a supervised medical weight loss program." Her doctor noted she was "highly motivated and compliant." She was on a fixed income. DENIED. A 55-year-old nurse. A nurse. Her own chart said "patient walks 4+ miles daily on 12-hour shifts, reports caloric intake under 1,300/day, continued abdominal weight gain since perimenopause." DENIED. There's a field at the bottom of each review where I can type comments. Most reviewers leave it blank. For a long time, I did too. Then one day I typed, in the comment box of a denial for a 60-year-old woman whose chart said she'd "cried throughout the visit," the words: "I'm sorry." My supervisor saw it in an audit and told me to never do that again. So I stopped. But I wanted to write so much more. Now let me tell you about the appeals. When a claim is denied, the patient can appeal. And sometimes, the appeals come with letters from the women themselves. Handwritten, sometimes. Scanned into the system. I've read hundreds. "I am not lazy." "I have done everything my doctor has asked." "I eat less than my husband and he is thin." "I don't understand why my body won't respond anymore." "I am begging you." One letter, from a 61-year-old woman in Bridgeport, said: "Please understand I am not asking for a vanity drug. I have been fighting this since I was 50 years old. I have tried every diet that exists. I am tired. I am so tired. My doctor says this is the only thing left. If you say no, I don't know what I will do." I had to deny the appeal. She didn't meet the criteria. I went into the bathroom on our floor and sat in a stall for twenty minutes. And then I went back to my cubicle, because there were forty more in my queue. And here's what made it worse. Some of the women who got approved, the ones who did meet criteria, I'd see their requests come back a year later. "Patient discontinued due to nausea and vomiting." "Patient discontinued due to cost after coverage change." "Patient reports weight regain following discontinuation." And then a new request, for the same drug, to start again. Over and over. And there's one more pattern I need to tell you about. The husbands. Sometimes a couple is on the same plan. Same employer. Same doctor. And sometimes both of them get the shot prescribed in the same month. The husband, usually, has type 2 diabetes. Approved. The wife, usually, is "only" prediabetic, or not yet. Denied. I've processed hundreds of those pairs. His and hers. Same kitchen. Same dinners. One gets it. One doesn't. And the wife's chart almost always says the same thing: "Weight gain since age 50. Adherent to diet. Frustrated." I think about those couples. Sitting at the same dinner table, him with his pen in the fridge, her with her calorie app, both of them wondering why she's the one who can't. Now I need to tell you about me. I'm 58. I'm an LPN by training. I worked in a nursing home for fifteen years before I came to the insurance side, because my back couldn't take it anymore. At 51, I got the belly. The same one I read about in every chart. Low and round and stubborn. My arms and legs about the same. Just the middle. I did everything. Twelve hundred calories. Walking at lunch around the parking garage, which in Hartford in February is a special kind of misery. Weight Watchers twice. It grew anyway. And one day, about two years ago, I was reading a chart on my screen. "Patient reports weight gain beginning around age 51, primarily abdominal. Adherent to 1,200 kcal/day. Walks daily. Persistent hunger. Frustrated and tearful." And I realized I could have been reading my own chart. And I realized that if I put in a request for myself, I would deny it. I'd stamp my own claim DENIED in four minutes, with a reason code from a dropdown menu. I took my headset off and stared at my monitor for a long time. My sister made it personal. Her name is Carol. She's 61. She lives in Springfield. She's on a different insurance plan than the one I work for. Last year her doctor prescribed one of the shots. She called me, excited. She said, "Di, you work in insurance. Will it go through?" I asked her a few questions. Did she have diabetes? No. Did her plan cover weight-loss drugs? She didn't know. I said, "Carol, honey, don't get your hopes up." Two weeks later, she got the letter. DENIED. She called me crying. She said, "Di, I read the letter three times. It says I don't meet the criteria. What criteria? I've been fighting this for eleven years." I knew exactly what criteria. I knew the dropdown menu. I could probably tell her the reason code. And I didn't know what to say to my own sister. She said, "Is somebody like you sitting in a cubicle somewhere saying no to me?" I said, "Yes, Carol. Somebody exactly like me." She was quiet for a long time. Then she said, "Do you ever wonder about us? The women you say no to?" I said, "Every day." That night, I went home and sat in my kitchen and looked at my hands for a long time. I'd been saying no to women like my sister for three years. And I still had no idea what was actually wrong with any of us. Here's how I found out what was really going on. This summer, a woman on my team, Rosa, 54, came over to my cubicle at lunch. She said, "Diane, you know how we're always saying these women's charts all sound the same?" I said, "Every day." She said, "My cousin sent me an article that explains why. I think you need to read it." She handed me her phone. The headline said, "Costco Shoppers Say This Fat-Burning Patch Triggers Weight Loss 'Unlike Any Other.'" In insurance, we see a lot of miracle-product claims. Wellness gimmicks. Supplements. We deny them all. I gave Rosa a look. She said, "I know. I know. Read the doctor. Then read the part about the hormone. It's every chart we've ever read." So I read it at my desk while I ate my yogurt. It's about a cardiologist in Cleveland named Dr. Sarah Mitchell. She spent four years investigating why her female patients over 50 couldn't lose belly fat, even on strict diets. And here's her quote. "I had patients eating 1,200 calories a day, walking five miles, and still gaining belly fat. The math didn't work. Something else had to be driving it." "Patient reports adherence to 1,200 kcal/day diet without significant results." I'd read that sentence six thousand times. And here was a cardiologist saying what none of those charts ever said. The math didn't work. The article says Dr. Mitchell had told her patients "eat less, move more" for decades. Then at 53, her own waistline grew four inches in a year without her changing anything. So she pulled the bloodwork from 217 of her female patients over 50 with belly fat they couldn't lose. And she found the pattern. It wasn't thyroid. It wasn't cortisol. It wasn't just insulin. It was GLP-1. The same hormone the shots I deny every day are built on. The article explains it. Your gut makes GLP-1 every time you eat. It tells your brain you're full. It slows digestion so your blood sugar doesn't spike and get stored as fat. And it signals your body to release stored fat, especially belly fat, and burn it. In your 30s and 40s, women make it at full capacity. After 50, it drops. Up to 67 percent lower in women over 50 compared to women in their 30s. And the steepest drop is between 50 and 58. I sat at my desk with my yogurt and thought about six thousand charts. "Weight gain beginning around age 50." "Persistent hunger." "Frustrated and tearful." It was all right there. The women weren't failing their diets. Their bodies had lost two-thirds of the hormone that tells them they're full and tells their belly to let go. And the only fix their doctors had was a shot that replaces that hormone. A shot I was paid to deny. There's a line in the article where Dr. Mitchell says women over 50 aren't eating more. In most cases they're eating less. But their bodies have lost the signal that tells fat cells to release. So no matter how little they eat, the belly fat just sits there. The article calls the old advice the "calories in, calories out" lie. And then it talks about the shots. It doesn't pretend they don't work. They do. But it lays out what I see in my queue. Nine hundred to fourteen hundred dollars a month out of pocket, because most insurance won't cover them for weight. I can confirm that. I'm the one who won't. A weekly needle in the stomach or thigh. Nausea in 44 percent of patients. The gaunt "Ozempic face." Shortages and waitlists. And up to 67 percent of people regaining the weight within a year of stopping. I see the re-requests. I can confirm that too. Then the article explains the patch. As a nurse, I went into that part with my claims-reviewer brain fully on. The article explains that pills and gummies lose 60 to 80 percent of their active compounds to stomach acid before reaching the bloodstream. That's real. That's why so many oral supplements do nothing. A patch skips the stomach and goes through the skin. It says that's the same reason hormone replacement therapy moved to patches decades ago. That's accurate. We cover estrogen patches every day. The patch is the size of a quarter, skin-toned, worn on the lower belly or hip, releasing slowly over eight to twelve hours. It doesn't replace the hormone with a synthetic one like the shots. It's designed to support your body making more of its own. And here's the part that matters to me professionally. It doesn't need a prior authorization. It doesn't need my approval. It doesn't need anybody's approval. The article explains what's in it. I'll let it do that. I'm a claims reviewer, not a chemist. I ordered it that night. Here's what happened. Days one through five, nothing. Day six, at 3 PM, which is when our floor always has somebody's birthday cake in the break room, I walked past the cake on my way to the printer. I didn't stop. I'd stopped at that cake every single day for six years. The article says most people notice appetite changes in the first five to seven days. Day six. By week four, my work slacks were loose. By week eight, I walked the parking garage at lunch, all six levels, and didn't stop on level four to catch my breath. By week ten, I had my own physical. My doctor looked at my chart and said, "Diane, your blood pressure's down. Your weight's down. What did you change?" I said, "I stopped waiting for approval." She didn't get the joke. I didn't explain. By week twelve, Rosa caught me in the hallway and said, "Diane, you look like a different woman." I said, "I'm the same woman. Just without the fight." The first person I sent the article to was Carol. She called me the next morning at 7 AM. She said, "Di. I read it four times." I said, "I know." She said, "So it's not that I don't meet the criteria. It's that I don't meet the hormone." I laughed for the first time in weeks. She's been on the patch for two months now. Last week she sent me a photo from her granddaughter's dance recital. Carol in the front row, in a fitted dress, standing up and clapping. Under it she wrote, "Approved." I'm not going to give you numbers. I see enough numbers on six thousand charts. But I'll tell you what I do now. I still work in prior authorization. I still have to deny the claims that don't meet criteria. That's my job. Those are the rules. I don't make them. But when a woman over 50 calls our member line to ask why her claim was denied, and the call gets routed to me, which happens a few times a week, I do something I'm not supposed to do. After I explain the denial, I say, "Ma'am, can I tell you something off the record?" And I tell them about the article. I tell them the name of it. That's all. I'm not selling anything. I just tell them it exists. Last month, a woman of 62 from Stamford called back. She asked for me by name. She said, "Diane, you told me about that article after you denied my shot. I read it. I want you to know I'm not hungry at night anymore. And I didn't need your approval." I took my headset off and cried at my desk. The other day, I typed "I'm sorry" in a comment box again. Old habit. Then I deleted it, before my supervisor could see. And I typed something else in my head instead. Something I'll never be allowed to type in that box. "It was never your fault. It's a hormone. There's an article. Read it." Maybe someday they'll let me type that. Until then, I'm typing it here. I'm not a doctor. I'm a prior-authorization reviewer who's stamped "DENIED" on six thousand women over 50. I don't sell this patch. I don't get anything. My company would probably fire me if they knew I wrote this. Nobody asked me to. I'm writing it at home, on a Sunday night, with the laptop I'm not supposed to use for this. Here's what I know. If your claim for the shot was denied, it wasn't because you didn't deserve help. It's because the system wasn't built to help you. A hormone that tells your brain you're full and tells your belly to let go drops by up to two-thirds after 50. That's what the shots replace. That's why they're so expensive. That's why the weight often comes back when you stop. And that's why "eat less, move more" never worked for you. Pills and gummies mostly get destroyed in your stomach. There's a page that explains every bit of it. The cardiologist and her four years. The 217 women. The "calories in, calories out" lie. Why the drop is steepest between 50 and 58. Why the shots cost what they cost, and what happens when you stop. Why a patch, the way hormones are already given. And what happened to the 47 women she tracked for fourteen months. It's the Costco shoppers article Rosa showed me at lunch. I want you to read it. Especially if you've ever received a letter with my kind of signature on it. 👇 Link below https://myhealthyshape.com/meta-src-us-ledisa-calories-lie-dct2 There's a line at the bottom of every denial letter we send. "This decision does not prevent you from seeking care." For the first time, I can tell you that's true. Diane, LPN, 58, Hartford, Connecticut P.S. If you're appealing a denial right now, keep appealing if your doctor says you need it. Sometimes we do overturn. But while you wait, read the article. You don't have to wait for anybody's approval to understand your own body. P.P.S. Rosa and I have started a quiet little club on our floor. Four women over 50 in prior auth, all on the patch. We meet at lunch and walk the garage. We call ourselves "The Approved." P.P.P.S. The article says the patch isn't sold in stores, pharmacies or on Amazon, only from the manufacturer, and it sells out and restocks every two to three weeks. It also has a 90-day money-back guarantee. In my whole career in insurance, I have never once seen a money-back guarantee. Not once.

Engagement over time

Not enough history yet to show a trend.