Erin Werner

The $695 test costs a year

I gave up food after food because of my migraines, and a year later I'm still super limited and it really sucks. 22 years of taking things out of my life, and then a woman in a grocery store asked me a question I couldn't answer. I'm 46. I've had migraines since I was 24. Last year I had 112 days with something on them and about 40 of those were the kind where the room has to be dark. I had a second food sensitivity panel booked. $695, not covered, no plan covers it, I checked twice because I couldn't believe it the first time. I already did one of these 4 years ago and the results were total bullshit. The red and yellow foods didn't line up with anything I had actually lived through, and after the elimination diet I started reacting to green foods that had been fine before. And I booked it again anyway. That's where I was 4 months ago. It started with the book. Heal Your Headache. Everyone in this has either read it or had it pushed on them by somebody who has. There's a list in it and you work the list, and my neurologist scoffed when I brought it up, which honestly only made me more sure. Chocolate went first. Then aged cheese. Then red wine, then anything fermented, then soy sauce and every other sauce that comes in a bottle, because once you start reading labels you find out that's most of them. Nuts. MSG. Caffeine, which I cut, then put back because I couldn't function, then cut again. I want to be fair to the diet because it did something. I cut tyramine out and my 3 day migraines turned into 1 day migraines. That is not nothing. When you've been having 3 day ones since your twenties and somebody hands you back 2 days, that is the best news anybody has given you in a decade. So I got stricter. That's the part nobody warns you about. When one thing works you don't stop, you push, because obviously you're onto something. The other thing that kept me going was the blue cheese. I ate a big chunk of it on a cracker and in 20 minutes my face turned bright red and my heart started racing and I stood there with my hand flat on my chest thinking, there it is, that's it, I got you. I told my husband. I put it in the app. Blue cheese, confirmed, done. I was so happy that day. I want you to understand that part. The $695 panel came after that, when the 1 day ones started creeping back toward 2. Red foods, yellow foods, green foods, a whole booklet of them. I ran the elimination off it for a year and by the end of that year I was reacting to things on the green list. Foods that had been safe. I would eat one and wait, and sometimes nothing, and sometimes a bad night, and there is no version of that where you conclude the booklet was wrong. You conclude you missed something. A year later and I was still super limited and it really sucked, and the thing it left behind wasn't even the migraines. Elimination diets teach your brain that food is unsafe and then your brain freaks out when you try to add it back in. I could not eat a cashew without my heart going. Not a migraine. Just fear, sitting in my chest, over a cashew. And it isn't only food. That's what people outside this don't get, they hear elimination diet and they picture a woman being fussy at a restaurant. Hot baths, gone. Naps, gone. Sleeping in on the weekend, gone, because sleeping in is one of the worst ones for me. Black tea including iced tea. Skipping a meal, ever, for any reason. Staying up late to finish something for work. A red eye flight. Not having to think about whether I'm carrying the pills, which I gave up so long ago I forget it was ever a thing. Movies. For a while I could still go if I brought the decibel filtering earbuds I found on Amazon and closed my eyes every time the screen started flashing. Then I stopped going. Concerts before that. Driving in the middle of the day in summer, I just don't. Then it got to the store itself. The bread aisle at Market Basket got me twice. At Hannaford it's the chemical aisle, and also the meat department, and I have never been able to explain the meat department to a single human being. I go the long way around now. I have a route. Work I can't give up so work just costs me. 2 monitors and the unfiltered fluorescents over my desk. My dad gave up hosting because of my migraines. He decided his house had mold and moved every family gathering to a breakfast place, all of them, birthdays, Easter, the whole calendar. It was so sweet of him. That house got torn down within weeks of them moving out, so who knows, maybe he was right. My in laws stopped using Carpet Fresh before I come over and threw out the Unstoppables. Everybody rearranged themselves around me. None of it worked. The medicine ran alongside all of this the whole time, I never stopped that. Topamax for a year. Propranolol. Amitriptyline. A triptan I ration. 2 rounds of Botox. None of that is what this is about. It's the background. I tracked it the whole way. Mine is simplistic, it's an analog bar chart of percent by month, I drew the axis myself with a ruler. I brought it to my neurologist. He didn't look at it. You keep a diary to learn your triggers and then a medical professional either refuses to look at it or discredits it, and then he asks well how many days is it, and the chart is right there in front of him, in percent, by month, for 3 years. So. 4 months ago, bread aisle, Market Basket, reading the ingredients on a bag of rolls. You check every one of them, because they can say ginger and mean ginger paste with preservatives in it, and a thing like that got past me for years once. A woman next to me says, is it the tyramine or the histamine. I said both. I said it like it was a joke and it was not a joke. Her name is Kathy, she's 63, and I have never seen her before or since. She did Buchholz in 2011. She did the tyramine diet. She paid for the panel, hers was the same $695 as mine. She did the strict low histamine reset, threw out everything in her kitchen and started over with a handful of foods and added one back a week, and she said at the time it felt like recovering from a lifetime of being poisoned, and she meant that as a compliment to the diet. I told her about the appointment. 5 weeks out, second panel, $695. And she said, can I ask you something before you pay for that again. Then she said, how many things are on the list. I have it in the notes on my phone because the testing place wants a food history. I stood there in the bread aisle and I counted it for her out loud. 41. 41 things. Foods, hours, places, a whole department of a grocery store, the movies, hot water. 22 years. She said, and how many days did you have last year. 112. She said, and before you started any of it. I don't have a number for before. I wasn't counting yet. What I have is my mother saying I was in bed 2 or 3 days a week in my twenties. She didn't say anything for a second. Then she said, so that's 41 things and 22 years and you're roughly where you started. I said the tyramine thing was real though. 3 days down to 1. That was real. She said, I believe you, it was real for me too. And then it stopped being real, right. And you went looking for what you missed. That's exactly what happened. Every single time. Then she pulled her phone out and found something, and she read the numbers off to me twice because she said nobody believes them the first time. 2023. They followed 1,125 people with episodic migraine for 90 days and logged 14,080 individual attacks. And they tested 47 possible triggers. Not 47 foods. 47 things, and food is only some of it, they had weather in there, and sleep, and exercise, and how you were feeling that day. 24 of the 47 came out the other way. More often tied to FEWER attacks instead of more. Caffeine. Alcohol. Chocolate. Sleeping well. Relaxing. Exercise. I went home and read the actual thing that night, and I want to be careful here because I had it wrong in my head at first. It does not say chocolate protects you. It says that in a big share of the people they tracked, in a proportion they call not negligible, the so called triggers behaved as protectors. Their own sentence at the end is that this challenges the recommendation of avoiding known triggers. I read that sentence 6 or 7 times. There's an older one too, from 2013, about why we're all so sure. The idea is that the attack has already started hours before you feel any pain, and one of the things a starting attack does is make you crave something. Sweet, usually. So you eat the chocolate because the migraine has already begun, and then the migraine shows up and you write down chocolate. The line in it, which it's quoting off two other papers, is that natural experimentation is not a reliable method for individuals to identify migraine triggers, which is a polite way of saying the diary can't do what all of us built our lives on it doing. Kathy said the part that actually knocked me over while I was still standing there with the rolls. She said, it's like a smoke alarm that goes off every time you make toast. You can throw out the toaster. You can throw out the bread. The alarm is still going to be too sensitive. And then she said, every single thing you have been handed in 22 years asks you to change. Cut this. Avoid that. Keep the diary. Take the pill after it already hurts. Not one of them goes anywhere near the nerve. 22 years and nobody had put it to me that way. My nerve overreacts. Something sets it off at a level that would do nothing to my husband, and it fires, and I get a migraine. Taking the meat department out of my life does not make that nerve calmer. It just means I don't walk down that aisle. What she was wearing was a ring. Plain metal band, on her index finger, and she'd been wearing it for 11 months. There is a pressure point on your index finger, and the ring sits on it and presses. All day. All night. That's the entire idea, and when she said it out loud next to the rolls I laughed at her. I laughed and then I stopped laughing, because I have been squeezing the web of my own hand since I was 24. In the car, in meetings, at 4 in the morning. My ex used to do it for me because he could get it harder than I could. I have tied a scarf around my head as tight as I could get it. I have wrapped an ace bandage as tight as possible and left it. Nobody taught me any of that. Every one of us does some version of it. And pressure on my head is a trigger, that's the stupid part. Ponytails set me off. Clips set me off. A headband is out of the question. This is a finger. It doesn't touch my head at all. Here's the piece I keep coming back to. A pill waits until it already hurts and then tries to catch up. Botox is 31 needles and 12 weeks of hoping. Acupuncture is 30 minutes on a table and then you drive home and it's over. The pressure never switches off. It's on your hand in the shower, it's on your hand while you're asleep, it's on your hand during the hours before an attack when you don't know anything is coming yet. Kathy's first month was nothing much. Her neck and her shoulders let go, and she slept, and that was it. The count started moving somewhere around week 5. She went from 12 days a month to 3. And then this past spring it went back up to 5 for a couple of months and she has no idea why, and she told me that part without me asking her, which is the reason I believed the rest of it. $29.90. That's the whole price, all 4 colors, same number. Surgical steel, an open band you bend with your fingers, one size, about 5 seconds and it fits, so there's nothing to measure. 4 magnets set into it. Water resistant, so it doesn't come off in the shower and it doesn't come off at night, which is the only part that matters. 2 of them are $49.80. Shipping is free, 3 to 5 days. 30 days to send it back for your money. No questions, and they don't charge you the return shipping. Put that next to the panel. $695, and when the results are bullshit nobody gives you the $695 back. My Imitrex copay is $45. The CGRP my neurologist keeps circling is $600 a month. Nobody has ever refunded me anything. I ordered it that night. Weeks 1 and 2, nothing you could put on a chart. My neck and my shoulders stopped being a board. I slept through, twice, which for me is news. Week 3 I had 2, which is a normal week for me, and I remember thinking, well, $29.90. Week 5 the chart moved. 4 days that month instead of 9 or 10. Week 6 I had a bad one that took a whole day off me and I lay there absolutely certain the ring was nothing and I'd been an idiot in a grocery store. Week 7 I ate a square of dark chocolate. You add them back one at a time, and then you wait, because that's what 22 years does to you, you don't get to just eat something. Nothing happened. Week 9 I had a glass of red wine at my dad's. At his house. Not the breakfast place. Nothing happened, and neither of us said anything about where we were sitting. Last month I had 3 days. From 9 or 10, every month, for as long as I have been counting. And I have not been able to make myself eat the nuts. Or the dairy. I know. I know exactly what I just told you, I know they aren't doing it, I have the numbers now and I still put the bag back on the shelf. If you want to know what 22 years of this actually costs, it isn't the migraines. It's that. Let me be straight about what this did and what it didn't. It did not give me back the 22 years. Nothing gives those back. It did not take the migraines away. I had 3 last month. The ones I get now are quieter, not gone, and 2 of the 3 I handled without taking anything, which I only noticed later. It does not tell me what my triggers are. After all of this I don't think that question has an answer for me. What it did is the count. And I have not crossed one more thing off since the day I met her, which I did not know could happen. I cancelled the panel. The woman on the phone did not sound surprised and she did not ask me why, which told me plenty. You know how many things are on your list. You don't have to sit there and count them like I did in the bread aisle, you already know roughly. I'm not telling you to go eat the cheese. Kathy never told me that either, and if she had I would have walked away from her right there in that aisle, the way I've walked away from every person who ever handed me a tip about my own head. Auvulis makes it. It's called the Vitality Ring. https://auvulis.com/products/vitality-ring P.S. The second panel wouldn't have cost me $695. It would have cost me another year. That's what the first one cost, a year of adding foods back one at a time and being frightened of every single one of them, and the fear didn't leave when the year ended. The diet teaches your brain that food is unsafe and then your brain freaks out when you try to put it back. 4 months in with the numbers in front of me and I still can't eat a cashew. Whatever the next round takes off your list, you don't get that back by stopping. P.P.S. The number I watch now isn't attacks, it's the list. That list went one direction for 22 years, every year, and it has not moved in 4 months. It's still your list. You can still put things back on it, and 30 days is long enough to find out whether it moves.

Engagement over time

Not enough history yet to show a trend.